An investment advisor who charges 2 percent of assets a year is called expensive, and the reason is arithmetic. On $1,000,000 that earns nothing, 200 basis points a year leaves $545,000 after thirty years. The fee is printed beside the balance on every statement because that is the only place it can be judged.
A community association has one pool of capital, its reserve fund, and it pays a stack of fees out of the same pocket that fills it. The management fee. The audit or review. The reserve study. Counsel. The interest on an insurance premium it could not pay in one sum. Each is approved on its own line of a budget, each is reasonable in its own market, and none is ever stated as a share of the reserve. This piece states them that way.
The Foundation for Community Association Research counts 373,000 associations in the United States, 29.6 million units, $124.2 billion of assessments a year, and $31.1 billion of that contributed to reserves. That is $1,051 a unit a year to the reserve. A management fee of $15 a unit a month, a middle figure for a managed association, is $180 a unit a year. If the reserve holds three years of contributions, $3,152 a unit, the management fee alone is 571 basis points of it every year. The $15 and the three years are assumptions, and the figure stands with them printed beside it until a measured one replaces it. The rest is the Foundation's.
Small associations pay the most, because the fee is charged by the unit and the reserve belongs to the building. One Washington association whose books are on CommunityPay held $35,000 in reserves and paid between $800 and $900 a month to be managed. That is 2,914 basis points a year on the only capital it has. Enter your own association below and the figures redraw.
What a fee of that size does over time is the part no budget shows. At 250 basis points a year, $1,000,000 held for thirty years with nothing earned is $467,884. Slightly over half is gone, and nothing was lost to a bad year, a bad manager, or a bad decision. It was paid out, two and a half percent at a time.
The reserve is usually not invested at all. It sits in a deposit account, and the dollar it sits in is not the dollar it was. The Federal Reserve's M2 measure of the money supply stood at $3.6 trillion in January 1996 and $23.4 trillion in September 2026, a sixfold increase, 6.3 percent a year. Since February 2020 alone it has grown 51 percent. Measured against that growth, a reserve held in cash for thirty years keeps sixteen cents on the dollar before any fee is paid. With the advisor's 200 basis points it keeps nine. With the modeled management fee it keeps three. The Washington association at 2,914 basis points does not get thirty years. Its reserve is down by half in the second year and keeps thirteen cents on the dollar by the fifth, which is the curve on the chart that falls off a cliff.
The same arithmetic runs the other way. $1,000,000 compounded for thirty years at 10 percent is $17.4 million. At 12.5 percent, the same 250 basis points kept and compounded, it is $34.2 million. At 15.7 percent, the modeled management fee kept, it is $79.6 million. An association that stops paying 2,914 basis points and contributes the money to its reserve instead adds 29 percent of its balance in the first year alone, before the reserve earns anything. That is a contribution, not a compounding return, and it is still the largest single move a small association can make.
No one has stated the drag this way because the buyer and the payer are different people. The manager chooses the software, the bank, and the vendors, and the owners fund the choice. Each professional's fee is set in its own market against its own peers, and no one is paid to add the column. Then the same association is told its reserve is underfunded, and the study that says so is one of the fees. The advice that comes with the finding is always the same: raise the dues, and an owner who cannot afford the increase should sell. No one in the room is paid to say that the fees could come down instead.
In September we wrote that community associations are the last mispriced asset class, $13.1 trillion of housing whose reserve health no buyer can see. The drag is the mechanism underneath the mispricing. The fund is not only underfunded. It is drawn down every year by the people engaged to protect it, at a rate no fund manager could charge and keep a client. The largest asset mispricing in the country is not on an exchange. It is in the building.
Keeping that return takes no sophistication, and the sophistication an association adds is usually what loses it. The rule is one sentence: a seat on the board is a job. One director keeps the books, on CommunityPay. One deals with the vendors. One runs the meetings and keeps the minutes. One holds the insurance and the reserve study. Each duty is one thing the others can check, and no seat exists for its own sake. A board whose members hold no duty governs by faction, and a board that governs by faction ends up hiring a manager to do the work it was elected to do, at the rate above. The governing documents that allow this are short. The ones that prevent it are long.
The modeled figure above is a model, and we intend to replace it. Associations post their approved budgets and year-end statements on their own websites, and the registry holds 187,000 of them to start from. A reader that finds each budget and takes four lines from it, the management fee, the reserve contribution, the reserve balance, and the insurance premium with its financing, produces a measured distribution by state and by size. When it exists, the 571 becomes a number with a count behind it, and this page will carry it. Until then the assumptions are printed where the figure is, and the calculator above takes any association's own books.
SOURCES Foundation for Community Association Research, 2025 U.S. National and State Statistical Review (373,000 associations; 29.6 million units; $124.2 billion of assessments; $31.1 billion to reserves). Federal Reserve Board, M2 money stock, seasonally adjusted, via FRED series M2SL, read November 6, 2026 ($3,647.4 billion in January 1996; $15,492.8 billion in February 2020; $23,413.9 billion in September 2026). The Washington association's figures are its own books, with its board's consent. The $15 a unit a month fee and the three-year reserve balance are stated assumptions. The curves assume no return where they say so, and the rates they name where they do not; none is a forecast.
Scott Vuilleumier · Founder of CommunityPay, Inc.
Data science, investment banking, and financial systems engineering and ledger design.